
What defences are available?
Nullity of the summons: under French law, it must specify and characterise the facts, state the applicable provision and comply with strict formal requirements; an irregular summons does not interrupt the limitation period.
The three-month limitation period, which the defence checks date by date.
Good faith: legitimate aim, no personal animosity, caution and moderation in expression, a serious investigation or reliable sources.
The defence of truth, which is subject to a specific procedure: notice must be served within ten days of service of the summons, setting out the facts to be proved, copies of the documents and the identity of the witnesses, failing which the right is forfeited (Article 55 of the French Press Freedom Act of 29 July 1881). It cannot be raised where the allegation concerns the person’s private life.
The statement being an opinion or value judgment rather than an allegation of a specific fact.
The excuse of provocation in insult (injure) cases, and the right to freedom of expression guaranteed by the European Convention on Human Rights.
How do the proceedings unfold?
After the summons, a scheduling hearing (audience de fixation) is used to organise the exchange of documents and written submissions; the trial takes place several months later. The court may impose a fine, damages and publication of the judgment, or acquit if good faith or truth is established.
What happens with a criminal complaint with civil-party petition?
Under French law, in press matters a criminal complaint with civil-party petition need not be preceded by an ordinary complaint. An investigating judge who is considering placing a person under formal investigation (mise en examen) informs them by registered letter, specifying the alleged facts and their legal characterisation. The judge cannot investigate the truth of the allegations, good faith or the excuse of provocation: these defences will be argued before the court (Article 51-1 of the French Press Freedom Act of 29 July 1881). Formal investigation is therefore common and does not prejudge the outcome of the trial.
Can you take action against an abusive complaint?
Yes. Under French law, when the proceedings end with the case being dismissed (non-lieu), the person prosecuted may claim damages from the civil party who acted abusively or to cause delay, and a civil fine may be imposed on that party.
What strategy should you adopt?
Decisions must be made quickly: challenge the procedure, defend on the merits, negotiate a right of reply or a takedown, or consider a claim for damages for abuse of process where the action is clearly intended to silence someone.
How Ghozlan Veil can help
The firm defends decision-makers, journalists, employees and companies facing prosecution, from the police interview or summons through to appeal.
Your case is handled by Sacha Ghozlan and Lucas Veil.
See also
Frequently asked questions
Should I delete the content?
Deleting it does not erase the offence, but it can affect discussions with the other side. The decision should be made with your lawyer.
Can I remain anonymous?
Not before the criminal courts, but the identification of the author can be challenged.
What do I risk?
A fine, damages and legal costs; media coverage is often the main risk to reputation.
How long do I have to offer proof of the truth of the allegations?
Ten days from service of the summons. This time limit is strict: once it has passed, the evidence is no longer admissible.
Does being placed under formal investigation for defamation mean I will be convicted?
No. Under French law, in press matters the investigating judge cannot assess the truth of the allegations or good faith; formal investigation is common and does not prejudge the judgment.
Does this affect you?
If you have received a court summons or a police summons, contact the firm immediately: the time limits for responding are short.
Ghozlan Veil – 79 avenue de Wagram, 75017 Paris – contact@ghozlanveil.fr

Get in touch
Describe your situation in a few lines: a partner will call you back. Communications with the firm are covered by professional secrecy (legal privilege).
Phone
06 59 32 17 68
06 26 01 51 40
Address
79, avenue de Wagram
75017 Paris
Follow the firm