
Criminal liability of business leaders: how far are they answerable for their company’s failings?
A workplace accident, an environmental offence, a breach of health, safety, competition or accounting rules. When an offence is committed within a company, the question quickly arises: who is answerable for it? The executive, an employee, the company, or all of them. This page sets out the principles, the role of delegation of authority (délégation de pouvoirs) and the available defences.
Under French criminal law, liability is personal: a person is answerable only for their own acts or for failings that can be personally attributed to them. However, because an executive has the power to organise, supervise and give instructions, they can be prosecuted when they personally took part in the offence or failed to meet the obligations the law places on them in the exercise of their duties.
There are two regimes:
Intentional offences: the executive is liable when they intended the act, ordered it, or knowingly allowed it to happen.
Unintentional offences (workplace accidents or environmental harm, for example). Article 121-3 of the French Criminal Code requires that the offender failed to exercise normal diligence in view of their duties, skills, authority and the resources available to them. Where the executive did not directly cause the harm but created or helped create the situation that made it possible, or failed to take the measures that would have prevented it, they are liable only if they manifestly and deliberately breached a specific duty of care or safety laid down by statute or regulation, or committed aggravated negligence (faute caractérisée) exposing others to a particularly serious risk of which they could not have been unaware.
What is delegation of authority?
Delegation of authority is the mechanism by which a company head entrusts an employee with responsibility for applying the rules in a defined area (safety, hygiene, environment, etc.). If the delegation is valid, criminal liability may be borne by the delegate rather than by the executive. Under French law, the case law of the Criminal Division of the Court of Cassation generally requires the delegate to have the competence, authority and resources needed to ensure effective compliance with the applicable rules.
Its validity is assessed case by case:
the delegate must genuinely have the knowledge, hierarchical authority and resources (budget, staff, equipment) to act;
the delegation must be precise, limited to one area and accepted; a written document makes it easier to prove, even if it is not always required;
an executive who remains involved in the decision, or who personally took part in the offence, cannot rely on it to escape liability;
some obligations cannot be delegated, in particular those relating to the general management of the company.
Even a well-designed delegation of authority does not confer “immunity”: investigators and the judge will scrutinise it, and a document signed after the events rarely convinces.
What should you do if criminal proceedings are opened?
The executive should have each person’s position reviewed without delay: who held which powers, which delegation, which resources, which warnings were passed on. Answers given to investigators must be consistent with these elements. The defence of the company and that of the executive must be considered together, and sometimes separately, from the moment of police custody (garde à vue) or the search.
Under French law, for certain offences, including corruption, influence peddling, laundering of the proceeds of tax fraud and tax fraud, the public prosecutor may offer the company a judicial public interest agreement (CJIP), the French equivalent of a deferred prosecution agreement. If a judicial investigation is opened, the executive may be placed under formal investigation (mise en examen) or given assisted witness status (témoin assisté).
How Ghozlan Veil can help
We advise decision-makers before a crisis (criminal risk audits, delegations of authority) and defend them throughout the proceedings, from investigation to judgment, alongside the company or separately from it.
We act from the investigation stage (voluntary interviews (audition libre), police custody, searches), during the judicial investigation (formal investigation, access to the case file, requests for investigative steps, applications for annulment) and before the criminal court (tribunal correctionnel), working where necessary with the company’s accountant or usual adviser.
Your case is handled by Sacha Ghozlan and Lucas Veil.
See also
Frequently asked questions
Is the executive always prosecuted when an accident or offence occurs in the company?
No. Their liability requires personal acts or a failing attributable to them, after examining their powers, their duties and the resources available to them at the time.
Does a delegation of authority always provide protection?
No. The judge reviews it: the delegate’s competence, authority and resources, whether the delegation was real rather than a sham, and whether the executive interfered in the delegated area.
Can an employee be held liable instead of me?
Yes, if they received a valid delegation or personally committed the offence. A token delegation, or one given to a person lacking competence or resources, does not relieve the executive of liability.
Should the company and the executive have the same lawyer?
Not necessarily, and often not. Where interests diverge (account of the facts, strategy, risk of one implicating the other), separate lawyers are preferable.
An investigation has been opened: what should I do?
Do not hand over documents or sign anything without taking advice. Contact a criminal defence lawyer promptly so that you are assisted from the first interviews and searches.
What is the effect of a change of executive?
Liability attaches to the period of the events: you need to identify who actually held power at that time and which delegations were in place.
Does this affect you?
If you are implicated or wish to put your organisation on a sound footing, contact the firm.
Ghozlan Veil – 79 avenue de Wagram, 75017 Paris – contact@ghozlanveil.fr

Get in touch
Describe your situation in a few lines: a partner will call you back. Communications with the firm are covered by professional secrecy (legal privilege).
Phone
06 59 32 17 68
06 26 01 51 40
Address
79, avenue de Wagram
75017 Paris
Follow the firm