
What is tax fraud?
Under French law, tax fraud (Article 1741 of the French General Tax Code) consists in fraudulently evading, or attempting to evade, the assessment or payment of tax, notably by failing to file returns, concealing sums or using other fraudulent schemes.
Intent is essential: a simple mistake, a difference of interpretation or negligence is not enough.
The law punishes simple fraud with five years’ imprisonment and a €500,000 fine; the penalties are increased to seven years and €3 million where the fraud is committed by an organised gang or involves certain aggravating circumstances.
The public prosecutor’s office does not always act on its own initiative. Under French law, a complaint for tax fraud is in principle filed by the tax authorities after a binding opinion from the Tax Offences Committee (commission des infractions fiscales). Where the reassessed tax exceeds €100,000 and carries certain penalties (80% or 100%, or 40% for repeat offences), the tax authorities must report the facts to the public prosecutor, without going through the Committee. The investigation may also start from a report by Tracfin (the French financial intelligence unit), an audit by a tax audit team or another criminal investigation (misuse of corporate assets (abus de biens sociaux), money laundering, undeclared work).
What can the tax authorities do before filing a complaint?
A desk audit or a tax audit of the accounts, with a proposed reassessment and penalties.
A right of search and seizure (tax search, visite domiciliaire) at the premises of the company or the decision-maker, authorised by the liberty and custody judge (juge des libertés et de la détention) where the tax authorities suspect fraud. Under French law, the operations take place in the presence of a senior police officer; the decision-maker may be assisted by a lawyer.
A right to obtain information from banks, customers, suppliers and third parties.
What are the lines of defence?
Challenging intent: no intention to defraud, a good-faith error, technical complexity.
Challenging the regularity of the procedure: validity of the search authorisation, conditions of the seizure, respect for the rights of the defence during the audit.
Distinguishing tax litigation from criminal proceedings: the reassessment and penalties are disputed before the tax courts, criminal liability before the criminal courts. The two strategies must be coordinated.
Regularisation: paying or regularising does not erase the offence, but may weigh on sentencing and on the direction the proceedings take.
For the companies concerned, the possibility of a judicial public interest agreement (CJIP), the French equivalent of a deferred prosecution agreement, where the fraud falls within the scope of this procedure.
What should be examined in the tax file?
The analysis of the file should cover, in particular, the following points:
The alleged facts: identifying the returns, transactions and tax periods covered by the prosecution.
Fraudulent intent: examining the evidence relied on to distinguish an intention to defraud from an error or a difference of interpretation.
The executive’s personal situation: assessing their actual role, the decisions taken and the factors that may give rise to their criminal liability.
The procedure: checking how the file was referred to the judicial authorities and whether the investigative acts were lawful.
Coordinating proceedings: aligning the tax challenge with the defence before the criminal court.
Regularisation and penalties: assessing the scope of the steps taken and their possible impact on the outcome of the proceedings.
How Ghozlan Veil can help
The firm defends decision-makers accused in white-collar crime cases, including tax fraud and laundering the proceeds of tax fraud.
The firm acts from the tax audit onwards, during a tax search, in police custody (garde à vue) or at interview, and then before the investigating judge or the criminal court (tribunal correctionnel), in coordination with the company’s tax advisers.
Your case is handled by Sacha Ghozlan and Lucas Veil.
See also
Frequently asked questions
Does a tax reassessment necessarily lead to criminal prosecution?
No. The vast majority of reassessments remain within the tax sphere. Criminal prosecution concerns the most serious or most clearly established cases.
Can I be penalised twice for the same acts?
Under French law, combining tax and criminal penalties is restricted by constitutional and European case law; the question must be examined case by case from the outset of the proceedings.
Is it worth regularising my situation before a complaint is filed?
Often yes, but the strategy must be set with a lawyer: a poorly prepared voluntary disclosure may also be read as an admission.
What should I do during a tax search?
Call a lawyer immediately, check the authorisation order, destroy nothing, do not sign without reading and have your observations recorded.
What is the difference between tax fraud and tax optimisation?
Under French law, tax optimisation means lawfully reducing one’s tax burden, for example by using the regimes provided for by law or by choosing, among several options, the one taxed least. It becomes abusive where the transactions are fictitious, or where they seek the literal application of a provision against the objective of its drafters, for an exclusively tax-driven purpose (abuse of law, Article L64 of the French Tax Procedures Code) or a mainly tax-driven purpose (Article L64 A). Abuse of law leads to a reassessment and, where applicable, penalties. It falls within the jurisdiction of the criminal courts only if the elements of tax fraud, and in particular intent, are present.
Does this affect you?
If the tax authorities have notified you of a significant reassessment or if a search is under way, contact the firm.
Ghozlan Veil – 79 avenue de Wagram, 75017 Paris – contact@ghozlanveil.fr

Get in touch
Describe your situation in a few lines: a partner will call you back. Communications with the firm are covered by professional secrecy (legal privilege).
Phone
06 59 32 17 68
06 26 01 51 40
Address
79, avenue de Wagram
75017 Paris
Follow the firm